“So, Janet, how have you been feeling since our last session?”
“Broken.”
“In what way?”
“In what way do I feel broken? You know, like in the typical broken way. Like if you imagine a vase dropping to the floor and shattering into a million pieces. And then maybe imagine trying to bend down and pick up the pieces, but in doing so you cut both your hands and feet on the ceramic shards. So now you’re sitting on the floor surrounded by pieces of your favorite flea market vintage vase and you’re bleeding. The blood is staining the ceramic shards so that instead of their pale oatmeal color they are turning a light rose shade. And as you’re sitting there in pain, both because you lost your favorite vase and because you now have cuts – and because you feel broken – you realize that you actually like the light rose color. So you think about just continuing to sit on the floor and allowing your blood to stain all the pieces of the vase. Because this rose color, it’s so much prettier.”
“I see. Well, that doesn’t sound too good.
“Nope.”
“I’m sure you’ve heard about the Japanese tradition of Kintsugi? The art of putting broken pieces of pottery back together with gold? It’s built on the idea that in embracing imperfections you can create an even stronger and more beautiful piece of art. Does that idea resonate with you at all?”
“No.”
“Why do you think it doesn’t resonate with you?”
“Well, first of all I don’t have any gold to repair the vase with. Second of all, I’m kind of like bleeding out on the floor, so I don’t really have the energy to repair anything.”
“I understand. I’m very concerned about you feeling broken. Are you having any suicidal thoughts?”
“You mean like taking the broken ceramic pieces and plunging them into my neck or heart?”
“Yes. Or, any other type of suicidal thoughts.”
“Not really. I’m too drained from feeling broken to take any action, so you don’t need to worry about that.”
“Okay. Remember in our last session I asked you to keep a Joy Journal? Have you written down any moments of joy from the last two weeks?”
“Let me check…My favorite bakery gave me an extra cupcake, so like I paid for one but got two. I don’t know if that qualifies, but I did write it down.”
“Good. What else?”
“I discovered an affordable eye cream that works just as well as the expensive one I was using.”
“Very good. What else?”
“I saw a very pretty red bird on the bush outside my house.”
“A cardinal?”
“What?”
“Was the bird a cardinal?”
“I don’t know. It was just a pretty red bird.”
“Excellent. What else?”
“That’s it.”
“Nothing else?”
“No. I mean as I told you at the beginning of the session I’ve been feeling broken. So my life hasn’t exactly been joy-packed.”
“Yes, totally makes sense. Listen Janet I have an idea, if you’re open to it.”
“What is it?”
“Let’s pick up all the broken pieces, one at a time. And you name each piece – for instance grief or loneliness – then we’ll explore the emotions that come up for you.”
“I’m open to that. I mean we’re going to be picking up like a bazillion pieces, but okay. I just have one request.”
“What is it?”
“The Joy Journal has got to go.”
Dr. Finkelstein smiled.